Survivor Community Forum

Lynne Spillman (Survivor Casting Director) - Rocks or Sucks?  XML
Survivor » Survivor: Samoa: Polls
Poll
Lynne Spillman's Performance as Casting Director
A - The show has been a success due largely to casting 25% [ 14 ]
B - Her use of Recruits while annoying to some has still improved the show 7% [ 4 ]
C - Doesn't mattter, you can find people at a taco stand or in a pile of applicants. Survivor works regardless of casting, its the show that rocks 41% [ 23 ]
D - Her use of recruits has damaged the quality of and enthusiasm for the show 11% [ 6 ]
F - Her use of recruits has severally damaged the quality of the show and the support of its fans. She should be relieved of casting duties for S21/22. 16% [ 9 ]
Total Votes : 56
Author Message
happypygmy

CBS Community Member
[Avatar]
Joined: 11/13/2009 16:13:44
Messages: 40
Offline


Don't think by voting she rocks it will help you one iota get discovered.

Thanks!

This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 11/21/2009 14:37:26

patdempster

CBS Community Member
[Avatar]
Joined: 11/17/2008 01:52:28
Messages: 224
Offline


Makes no difference to me how people come to find themselves on the show. I can't see how it could effect the show once they hit the shores of wherever they are set down to play the game. It would be interesting to see some stats on how far the 'recruits' get in the game compared to how far the applicants get in the game. I've no idea who is a recruit and who is an applicant so those stats would be interesting.

happypygmy

CBS Community Member
[Avatar]
Joined: 11/13/2009 16:13:44
Messages: 40
Offline


Pat, the evaluation of recruits v applicants based on how far they go is more complicated than it might appear. The problem is that the casting has not been a random sample of each group. For example, the pure applicants on Samoa are Shambo 45, Betsy 48, Mike 62, and Russell S 42 ... all over 40. Realty Blurred has info on the schism inside SEG and CBS over the use of recruits and the assertion that applicants are used to fill "fodder" slots to prop up Lynne's recruits. Then there is the issue of the half applicants - those people who apply to TAR/BB/Pirates that get sent to Survivor, a rather solid group in Samoa; Ashley 22 (TAR), Natalie 26 (TAR), Laura 39 (TAR), Russell H 36 (Pirates). Tocantins was won by one of only 4 applicants, JT. Fiji had only 1 of 20 (one recruit walked off the set hours beore filming started) who was an applicant, the 53 year old and very fodder like, Gary.


I am still trying to compile a list of recruits versus applicants for all seasons. But as a proxie for recruits, Californians have finished one position lower (eliminated sooner) on average than the rest of the states, Among states with a statistically signifcant sample, Pennsylvanians are #1. In fact, Californians have finished lower than over 40s (who finish below 20s who finish below 30s).

This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 11/21/2009 10:18:33

 
Survivor » Survivor: Samoa: Polls
Go to: