When America gave Shelby the "Eliminate 3 Eviction Votes" Care Package.
During Week 5 of Big Brother: Over the Top, America gifted Shelby with what might've been the biggest game-changer of the season, so far—the choice to eliminate three votes from the next live eviction ceremony.
After the 24-year-old law-school grad opened her Care Package and announced her advantage to the group, everyone's faces grew heavy and worrisome, especially those in the Late Night Jamboree.
At the latest live eviction ceremony, Shelby decided to eliminate Jason, Justin, and Kryssie's votes (Late Night Jamboree), leaving only Ball Smashers Alex, Whitney, and America to decide. Their three votes resulted in a unanimous decision to give Scott the boot from the BB:OTT house.