3. John vs. the coconuts (Survivor: Marquesas)
You are what you eat. After a meal that included coconuts and a challenge featuring them as well, all of the castaways realized their possible exit order. John was super cocky during the challenge, assured that Sean would be voted out of the game.
However, in a last minute twist, John was actually the eighth person to be voted off during Season 4.
Watch all past seasons of Survivor on CBS All Access.