Not only did this date end in tears—it ended in fire!
Trying to impress Colleen, Matt Short lied and said that his beater was a collectible car that he'd won at auction. While having dinner, the car burst into flames in the parking lot. That's not all. Colleen later revealed that she was supposed to get married to her ex that evening. It seemed like a mess, but the two still kept dating. This goes to prove that sometimes the way things start doesn't tell you how they'll end.
Watch Life in Pieces on CBS.