NCIS - "The Meat Puzzle"
In this head-scratcher of an NCIS episode, Ducky attempted to reassemble the bodies of three mutilated victims who were stuffed into barrels. During this, he made the horrifying discovery that they were the bodies of a prosecutor and sheriff he worked with on a case 10 years earlier. Worse, it seems Ducky had become the murderer's next target.
Watch "The Meat Puzzle" (Episode 13, Season 2 of NCIS) on CBS All Access.
Watch new episodes of NCIS on Tuesdays at 8/7c on CBS and CBS All Access.
See which other special Halloween episodes made the list!