Andrea Boehlke and Matt Elrod
First together: Survivor: Redemption Island, Season 22 (2011)
Current status: No longer together
When Matt told Andrea that being around her made him feel more at home, she got a sparkle in her eye, and nodded in agreement.
Unfortunately, as soon as Andrea and Matt's budding romance grew more serious, Boston Rob—someone who obviously knew just how strong a pair could be in the game—worked on a scheme to split them up and the cute blondes didn't pick things up where they left off after Matt was voted out in the second episode.
Watch Season 23 of Survivor on CBS All Access to see how Andrea Boehlke and matt Elrod first met.