Terry Deitz (Season 12)
When his La Mina tribe went into the Survivor: Panama merge behind in the numbers, this challenge beast—protected by an Immunity Idol he found on Exile Island—pulled out all the stops and won five consecutive Individual Immunities. Deitz would ultimately fall short at the final challenge, getting voted out at Final 3 by Danielle DiLorenzo.
Deitz returned for Survivor: Cambodia (Season 31), but had to leave the game on Day 13 due to a family emergency.
Watch all past seasons of Survivor on CBS All Access.