5 Big Brother Underdogs

4/5

Donny Thompson (Season 16)

No one who watched his season would mistake him for a strategic genius, but Donny’s fellow Season 16 Houseguests were convinced the mild-mannered groundskeeper from North Carolina was a secret FBI agent. Perhaps they were tricked by his strong performance in competitions: Donny won three Veto competitions, allowing him to stay in the game until Week 9 without a solid alliance.

Watch every season of Big Brother on CBS All Access.